The 11-19 inch adjustable Baggershield works for me... Wind noise on highway is minimal and I can hear radio pretty well...But, windshields are many and so are owners needs and desires..What works for some, others do not like...Many choices so I guess it is up to you in the end...I have not tried any other brands at this point, but other riders have used various types and styles...Even some prefer the "useless" stock one....but that is why we have choices!!!