To me, #2 would be just as much a pain in the a$$ as what we have now. I like to be able to walk out in the garage and open my bags without any key involved. I just want to be able to lock or unlock the bags and remove the key in either position. JMHO. My little radio knob is the best solution for me if I cannot remove the key in the unlocked position.
One option that has worked well for me is to disable the lock on one side. This allows one side for quick access with no key but still have the second side if you want to lock something up.
What would be the difference between walking with the key (made with knob) in the lock or leaving the bag open all the time? I leave my key in the lock, it will not start the bike, and if I am at the motel, I lock the lock and take it out. This is the same as leaving it unlocked and locking at the motel for the night.
I must admit the locks can be a pain.
i keep my extra key in my pocket becuse just about every time i start to warm my bike up
i have to shut it down to get somthing.
Also if im going on a good ride i just leave the spair key in the trunk hole.