You really have to ride behind the Madstad before you can fully appreciate the difference.

Yep. Wife an I switched bikes a couple weeks ago so she could see the difference. She was 'perfectly happy' with her Baggershield Convertible,,, until she road my bike...

I'd go;

Buffeting:

Madstad 15" = 9.5
Baggershield convertible in the 'full up' position. (20.5" above rubber strip) ~8~

Wind noise:

Madstad 15" = 9.5
Baggershield convertible in the 'full up' position. (20.5" above rubber strip) ~6-7~