I had heel /toe on my '05, 1700 Road Star & my '16 Indian Chief. The Road Star came with one so it was made for it, worked great. Chief seemed to work okay but I only put 600 miles on it, then sold it. All my other bikes have been toe shift. I haven't a favorite, like or dislike one over the other. Unless there's a physical reason for the heel / toe, I would give it lots of thought after reading bob109's post.