Quote Originally Posted by unsub View Post
Mine behaved like that from the factory.

If you haven't already done so, I'd suggest take the trim off, take the 4 pins out and re-align the cubby. The cubby should sit squarely in it's place without any downward pressure needed to re insert the pushpins. Maybe something underneath preventing proper placement?
I’ve had it out played with it a few times. I just figure it has a “push three times to open” sticker on it somewhere.